Saturday, May 21, 2022
More

    Latest Posts

    NASU holds emergency meeting Tuesday, may call off strike

    The Non-Academic Staff Union of Educational and Associated institutions is set to hold an emergency meeting on Tuesday, May 24, 2022, Saturday PUNCH has...

    Deborah: Violent Sokoto protest that leaves shops looted, churches destroyed

    Normalcy has yet to return to Sokoto State a week after a protest by some youths calling for the unconditional release of those arrested...

    Electoral Act: PDP complies with amended section to elect delegates

    The party made the declaration in a statement issued in Abuja on Saturday by its National Organising Secretary, Umar Bature. Bature stated that the decision...

    ‘Funke and my dad cheated on each other’ – Funke Akindele’s stepson continues to drag her on Instagram

    In an Instagram Live video shared via his page on Friday, May 20, 2022, Benito revealed several shocking details about the actress and his...

    Court: States have power to ban open grazing

    A Federal High Court sitting Abuja has given the Benue State Government the legal muscle to enforce its Open Grazing Prohibition and Ranching Establishment Law 2017.

    According to Justice Ijeoma Ojukwu, the anti-grazing law, having been validly made by the state’s House of Assembly, and having not been invalidated by any competent court, remains a valid law, which is enforceable by the state, using all legitimate law enforcement agencies.

    Ojukwu in a judgment read during virtual court proceedings on Thursday however declined to compel President Muhammadu Buhari to instruct security agencies to enforce the law.

    The plaintiff, Matthew Tile Nyiutsa, a lawyer and indigene of Benue State, had sued Buhari, claiming that the President, by his oath of office, incurred a mandatory obligation to uphold and preserve the law of the land, but had failed to abide by his oath when he refused to implement the Benue State’s Open Grazing Prohibition and Ranching Law.

    Nyiutsa added that despite the existence, herders have remained unrelenting in practising open grazing, engaging in killings and destructions, but that the President has failed or refused to enforce the law in line of his oath of office by using the security and enforcement apparatus within his powers.

    But in the Thursday judgment, Ojukwu held that the failure of the President to discharge his official responsibilities in accordance with his oath of office is not justiciable and that the court cannot hold the President accountable for not abiding by his oath of office.

    “In my view, the courts do not have the vires to entertain any suit bordering on compliance with the oath of office of the President for the reason that it is not justiciable.

    “When the person, in this regard the President, fails to abide by the oath, the National Assembly, in line with the set down procedure, may consider it a misconduct in the performance of the functions of his office and take the appropriate measure under the Constitution. It is not the duty of this court adjudicate on.

    “The plaintiff may have genuine concern in respect of the facts averred, but there are procedures set out by law to address issues concerning citizens’ rights and violations.”

    Justice Ojukwu said the Benue anti-grazing law, having been validly made by the state’s House of Assembly, and having not been invalidated by any competent court, remains a valid law, which is enforceable by the state, using all legitimate law enforcement agencies.

    She said: “There is no contest that the Open Grazing Prohibition and Ranching Establishment Law 2017 was validly passed by the Benue State House of Assembly and that the law is still in force, especially as the law has not been struck down by any court of law or court of competent jurisdiction.

    “The implementation, therefore, lies with the machineries of the state and law enforcement agencies like the police, whose duty is to maintain law and order and to secure lives and properties in accordance with Section Four of the Police Act.

    “It behoves the people of Benue State and law enforcement agencies, task force, etcetera to employ all legitimate means to implement that law.

    “It is not the duty of the defendant on record. It is only where there is an infraction of the provision of that law that the court may be invited to impose the prescribed sanctions

    “In so far as the President has not issued any Executive Order, which runs contrary to the said law, this court cannot hold him accountable.

    “In the same vein, the court is not the appropriate arm to check any infraction in the performance of the functions of the office of the President arising from the oath of office taken by the President on the assumption of his duty as the President of the Federal Republic of Nigeria.

    “That duty or obligation belongs to the National Assembly, through the process prescribed by the Constitution,” the judge said.

    Justice Ojukwu equally held that by the provision of Section 308 of the Constitution, the plaintiff was wrong to have sued President Buhari in his personal capacity on an issue that relates to the performance of his official responsibilities.

    “The immunity provided in Section 308 of the Constitution is to protect the occupier of the offices named in the section against the institution of either civil or criminal suit against him/her in the section from being sued in his personal capacity while in office.”

    She said although the suit was in relation to the responsibility of the President in his official capacity, the plaintiff went outside that official capacity by adding the personal name of the name – Muhamadu Buhari – to the suit as a defendant.

    “The proper defendant in this case ought to have been the President, Federal Republic of Nigeria. The life of this suit cannot be sustained if, for any reason, President Muhammadu Buhari ceases to be in office, this suit will automatically abate since it cannot be sustained by any other President, his personal name haven’t been attached.

    “This cannot be the position of the law since governance is a continuum and does not terminate because the tenure of office of a particular office holder has elapsed.

    “The proper defendant in this case, in the alternative, should have been the Attorney General of the Federation, and the defendant on record (Buhari) as a nominal party. Or, in the alternative, the President, the Federal Republic of Nigeria,” Justice Ojukwu said.

    Governors of the 17 southern states agreed at their recent meeting in Asaba, Delta State, to ban open grazing in their states.

    Latest Posts

    NASU holds emergency meeting Tuesday, may call off strike

    The Non-Academic Staff Union of Educational and Associated institutions is set to hold an emergency meeting on Tuesday, May 24, 2022, Saturday PUNCH has...

    Deborah: Violent Sokoto protest that leaves shops looted, churches destroyed

    Normalcy has yet to return to Sokoto State a week after a protest by some youths calling for the unconditional release of those arrested...

    Electoral Act: PDP complies with amended section to elect delegates

    The party made the declaration in a statement issued in Abuja on Saturday by its National Organising Secretary, Umar Bature. Bature stated that the decision...

    ‘Funke and my dad cheated on each other’ – Funke Akindele’s stepson continues to drag her on Instagram

    In an Instagram Live video shared via his page on Friday, May 20, 2022, Benito revealed several shocking details about the actress and his...

    Don't Miss

    Tems debuts No.1 on Billboard Hot100 chart

    Temilade Openiyi, Nigerian singer professionally known as Tems, has made her debut at the No. 1 spot on Billboard Hot 100 charts.

    Why we want Jonathan back in Aso Rock – Fulani Group

    Hours after former president Goodluck Jonathan publicly rejected the All Progressive Congress’ presidential expression of interest and nomination forms, Secretary of the...

    Presidential bid: INEC, CBN partnership under threat over Emefiele’s APC membership

    The Nigerian Bar Association and civil rights groups on Monday warned that Central Bank of Nigeria Governor, Mr. Godwin Emefiele’s involvement in...

    Acting in Blood Sisters drained me mentally – Deyemi Okanlawon

    Popular Nigerian actor, Deyemi Okanlawon, has detailed how his role in Nigeria’s Netflix original series, Blood Sisters, affected him mentally.

    Lagos Assembly backs Tinubu’s endorsement of Sanwo-Olu, Hamzat

    The Lagos State House of Assembly has lauded the former governor of the state, Sen. Bola Tinubu for officially endorsing the state...

    Stay in touch

    To be updated with all the latest news, offers and special announcements.